Why Andy Burnham's stance on EU membership is an insult to Scottish Voters
By Zack McJimpsey
Andy Burnham has now decided that he wants to reopen a debate on EU membership but is still turning a blind eye to the issue of Scottish Independence.
He is now openly admitting to wanting to start the process of looking at re-entering the customs union and the single markets. Leaving these was meant to be some of the main benefits of Brexit and reversing these decisions would look like a betrayal of Brexit and what we were meant to gain from it.
EU flags - via Unsplash
However, since Andy Burnham wants to reopen the wounds from the decision only 10 years ago, then it would be unwise of him not to look back at a different decision 12 years ago - the Scottish independence debate. The situation with independence has arguably changed more than Brexit. In 2014, we were told the opposite of what happened in terms of EU membership, Oil and Gas, and even just getting some of the additional powers that Holyrood was promised.
Public opinion on both issues has changed. In the case of Scottish independence from the 55% no and the 45% yes result of the 2014 current polling, conducted by Norsat for the Sunday Times, gave a lead of 3% to yes. Polling for the EU referendum has also changed. In response to a YouGov survey, 56% of people would be in favour of rejoining the EU, with 73% wanting a wanting a closer relationship.
So in this case, Burnham is listening to public opinion to try and build a closer relationship. But when it comes to Scotland, there is similar sentiment but without any change in the opinion of Westminster politicians means that there is a democratic deficit between what Scotland wishes and isn't getting, and the opinion of people within the whole of the United Kingdom.
Scotland flag - via Unsplash
So, if Andy Burnham is wanting to ignore that wish along with the fact that the recent Holyrood election that delivered 72 pro-independence MSPs. The fact is that there is more of a mandate for the Scottish Independence question than there is for EU changes - with only 85 of the MPs elected in 2024 having the rejoin in their manifesto.
So, if he wants to reopen this wound from our past then I would say that public and political pressure is stronger with the independence question, and yet it is still being rejected at every turn for the sole reason being that no Prime Minister in Westminster wants to be the one that is in power when the union is eventually broken up.