The Body, why does female led and queer media often not gain the same support or recognition as male led media

By Claire Jordan

The Body Photo from Netflix Media Centre

Last week on the 11 October, Netflix released a new original show called ‘The Body’ which was watched by over five million people in the opening week.

It revolves around a group of girls in a private catholic school in 2004, it contains themes of Catholicism, religious and family trauma and loss of faith, along with themes of sexual repression and shame, it is a deep psychological drama with elements of comedy.

The girls decide to host a Halloween party as an initiation ritual for a new member of their school dance team The Lions, in which a young girl Grace along with the other girls partake in alcohol and other mind altering substances.

All goes wrong when Grace falls into a catatonic state and the town falls into a spiritual psychosis viewing her as a new saint to save them from their sins.

Due to the shows obvious religious themes and criticisms of the culture and how when faith is used in the wrong way can cause harm to communities, many people that are apart of Christian and Catholic faiths found the show to be offensive.

Due to this, a petition to have Netflix remove the show from the streaming platform reached over 100 thousand signatures with people describing the show as ‘offensive’ and ‘a false representation of the religion’ the petition claimed, “we are encouraging Christians to take 30 seconds right now and stand up for your faith by signing.”

But is this the true reason the show faced such overwhelming attacks? Considering that the show has a large majority teenage girl led cast along with a lesbian relationship we have to wonder if that has anything to do with the backlash.

Especially when compared to shows like Heated Rivalry which also came out earlier this year, however one main difference is the majority male led cast and the central love story revolving around two men.

Often shows that are more popular with young girls with female casts and shows that revolve around a lesbian love story opposed to a gay story often are cancelled early or do not receive the same main stream success.

Some examples include Killing Eve which was abruptly cancelled after four seasons, I Am Not Okay With This, Girls and Everything Sucks were all cancelled after one season, with Autostraddle writing “in our database of TV shows featuring lesbian, bisexual, queer and trans characters that only lasted for one mere season on this earth. Of those, around 67 are limited series, which leaves us with 189 TV shows with queer women and/or trans characters that were cancelled after one season — shows that got born, crawled into the world, won us over with their queer storylines, and then got cancelled.  but when it comes to shows with LGBTQ+ women and/or trans leads, we’re especially prone to getting an axe after season two or three.”

So why do these shows not receive the same commercial success as their male led counterparts and when they do, they are called to be cancelled, it seems anything teenage girls relate to seems to be met with negative reactions, as things that interest them are not taken as seriously and not seen as true art or to have substance.

Which is a tragedy as teenage girls tend to run fandom culture, dating all the way back to the 60s with bands like The Beatles or Elvis, who at first had a majority teenage girl audience and were not taken as seriously it was only when men entered the space they were recognized as true artists.

Teenage girls crave media the relate to, especially ones from LGBTQ+ communities as they may already be deprived of community so media may be their only escape, it seems the truly cannot win, Jennifers Body explains this perfectly “hell, is a teenage girl”.

The Body is well enjoyed by young girls and women as it delves into the psychological horror that they relate to the most as it deals with things like sexual repression, friendship dramas and deep personal identity issues, something they can often struggle with.

Hopefully The Body with its mass success can be the end of the cycle of women led and queer shows being cancelled early and be the start of a new era for media.